Turning the Tide: Principled Determination in a Time of Crisis

An update from the front lines of Massachusetts

Last night, I slept in my bed.

Normally, such an action is not newsworthy, but for me, it was the first time I had slept in my bed since the night of October 23rd, 2009.  Like hundreds of other students, religious leaders, and community members across the Commonwealth of Massachusetts participating in The Leadership Campaign, I have been refusing to sleep in my home powered by dirty electricity until the state implements a policy before December 7th (the start of Copenhagen) to Repower Massachusetts with 100% Clean Electricity by 2020.

100% Clean Electricity is an ambitious goal, or so I’m informed. I invariably reply that sometimes the impossible is necessary. And the necessity of passing legislation, or actually beginning the transformation that will let us live in a just and stable world is understood by a staggering amount of people, both students and community members. At last Sunday’s Sleep-Out  on the Boston Common, we had well over a hundred people there. While that number may not be staggering, the fact that 120 people stayed to receive citations from police, even when explicity told they could leave, staggers me. Here are people who understand the seriousness of the crisis we are all in, people willing to stand by there values.

So why did I give in?  It was not a conscious decision.  I fell ill on Tuesday, and started feeling much worse yesterday.  My girlfriend strongly encouraged me to get a solid night’s rest in bed, and I begrudgingly agreed to go and lie down in bed for a bit, not quite agreeing but realizing it was likely that I would not emerge until the next morning.

I have little to comment about my lapse.  I recognize that the hundreds of millions of climate refugees who will soon be forced from their homes will not likely get to ‘take a break’ when they get sick.  Indeed, malnourished refugees are more often than not probably going to be fighting off one disease or another.  Nor will they get to rise from their nice, warm sleeping bags in their dry tents and walk a short distance to a warm shower to start upon their day.

Perhaps, then, this movement will require higher degrees of sacrifice for us to convey the seriousness and the urgency of global destabilization as a result of rapid climatic disruption.  But that is for another post.  For now, I would like to comment on where we are, after three-and-a-half weeks of sleeping out.

A Brief Summary

We are calling on the elected officials of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts to pass a bill to Repower Massachusetts with 100% Clean Electricity by 2020.  Towards this end, students and community members across the state have been sleeping outside to protest the dirty-electricity that powers our homes, schools, businesses, and places of worship, and to draw attention to our world of contradictions.

Is it working?

I’ll let the reader be the judge of that.  But here, is an update, after some 25 days of sleeping outside.

Politics

We have recruited 21 state legislators (out of a total of 200) who have agreed to sign on to our letter to Governor Patrick, asking him to introduce our bill for 100% Clean Electricity by 2020.  We had a meeting on Tuesday with Governor Patrick, Secretary of Energy and Environmental Affairs Ian Bowles, and Assistant Secretary of Energy and Environmental Affairs for Policy, David Cash.  These three leaders listened attentively to our impassioned plea, and are expected to get back to us tomorrow with their assessment of Massachusetts’ potential to lead the world to a safe and stable future.  If the Governor does not feel suitably prepared to introduce our bill, we have a state legislator who has confirmed his willingness to do so at any moment.

We’ve also gotten the attention of senate candidate Alan Khazei (who might pop in for a visit) and Senator John Kerry who said that “this kind of grassroots activism sends a strong message across Massachusetts that climate change must be addressed now, not years from now.”

Media

We have had over fifty media hits, from outlets as diverse as campus newspapers, the Boston Globe, NPR, ABC, NBC, U.S. News and World Report, Science Magazine, Daily Kos, Grist, and the Weekly Dig.

Leading Organizations

Support for 100% Clean Electricity has continued to build.  In addition to Students for a Just and Stable Future (formerly Massachusetts Power Shift, the lead group), The Leadership Campaign has been endorsed by over two-dozen groups including religious organizations (Massachusetts Council of Churches, Religious Witness for the Earth, and others), community groups (Massachusetts Climate Action Network, Somerville Climate Action Network, Massachusetts Coalition for Healthy Communities), and even a political party (Massachusetts Green/Rainbow Party).  We are thrilled to have the support of all of these groups, and excited to have more join us in the weeks to come.

Supporters

A number of prominent individuals have brought us support in our struggle, including Bill McKibben and Dr. James Hansen, religious leaders like Episcopalian Bishop Bud Cederholm and Rev. Jim Antal, and political candidates (former Green Party gubernatorial candidates Grace Ross and Jill Stein).

Police Interactions

For better or for worse, it is illegal to be on the Boston Common after 11:00PM.  While this ordinance was passed with the most sincere of intentions, one wonders what our forbearer’s would think of our Commonwealth when people receive citations for demonstrating on the Commons.  Does democracy really close at 11:00PM?

We believe it does not, and have as a result decided to stand our ground on the Boston Common, and accept the legal consequences (a misdemeanor trespassing charge).  We hold no grudges against the courteous police officers who give us citations every week.  Indeed, we recognize they, like us, have a job to do.   Their primary duty is to enforce the law and keep the people safe, and we respect and applaud their efforts towards that end.

Most of the above leaders have even stood with us in the face of police citations for trespassing on the Boston Common (where we gather every Sunday evening).  If we make it to court, it should be a pretty good trial, complete with clergy in collars, a respected NASA scientist, and a world-renowned journalist and activist.

Student Power

But perhaps the most exciting achievement to date so far has not been the political support we have won, the prominent individuals and organizations who have come to our aid, or the media attention we have garnered.  Rather, it is the building of bonds across colleges and universities.   We, the students, are growing closer and closer together with each passing sleep-out.  With every tent we put up and every tent we take down, we are building the bonds of friendship that will make this movement win.  Hundreds of students have taken part, and each one has realized that they are a part of something bigger than themselves.  They have felt, and they have come to learn the names, faces, and stories of those who stand (and sleep) beside them.  As more community members join our sleepouts, they, too, our building with our students and with each other the relationships so needed to change the movement.

The Means Are The End

While the tactic seems to be fairly successful at earning us attention and demonstrating the depth of our resolve, it has also done wonders to help us see each other in a new light.  Not as students, not as community members, but as people possessing the principled determination we need to win.

We are going to win.

We are going to win because we believe in the strength of humanity.  We are going to win because we believe that our leaders, when presented with the dire predictions of science, will rise to the occasion.  We are going to win because realize what is at stake – our futures, and indeed, our very lives – and we treat the situation accordingly.  We are going to win because we are willing to sacrifice something morally significant – not just a warm bed, but in many cases, classes, grades, study abroad opportunities, criminal records, or career choices.

We are going to win because we will not stop until every single fossil fuel facility in our state ceases emitting greenhouse gases.  We are going to win because we will not stop until there is a solar panel on every roof, thick insulation in every building, and a wind turbine on every hill.

The question is not if we win, but when we win.  And that is a question I cannot answer.

But I can say this:  When future generations look back upon our time, and ask what the human race was doing when the world was burning, they will be able to look at the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, and find people who swam against the tide, who spoke out when others were silent, who stood (and slept) for justice.

And P.S.  I’m still sick, but I’m going to be sleeping in a tent again tonight. :)

12 Responses to “Turning the Tide: Principled Determination in a Time of Crisis”


  1. 1 Gabriel Elsner Nov 20th, 2009 at 12:21 am

    Craig,

    You’re an inspiration. I’m with you in spirit and hope to be sleeping in a tent soon.

    -Gabe

  2. 2 John Doyle Nov 20th, 2009 at 1:06 am

    So much respect for everybody participating

  3. 3 Jay O'Hara Nov 20th, 2009 at 1:13 am

    I don’t think I have every experienced anything quite as breathtakingly powerful as what happened this past Sunday night on Boston Common. Having been to dozens of protests, gone to the FTAA protests in Miami, plenty of SOA protests etc., I was almost breathless with what happened and could only respond by telling everyone “you look beautiful out here tonight.”

    Here’s the setup: 2AM, the 15 Boston Police officers arrive at the Common and inform us that if we do not leave our tents we will be arrested. 124 students assemble on the broad walk-way (the one in the above photo) that leads to the state-house. Once all are assembled (nobody remains in the tent to be arrested), the officers very loudly say to us that we are free to leave if we do not want to get a court summons for trespassing, but if we remain we will be cited. He said “Anyone who wants to leave should leave now.” AND NO ONE BUDGED.

    A profound moment: 124 students, community members and Bill McKibben hold tight to their convictions, take the harder road, stand up for global climate justice and stand to fight for what is right. Wow.

  4. 4 Eddie Miller Nov 20th, 2009 at 2:49 pm

    2:30 AM, reading Thoreau’s Walden by lamplight, watching the police drive away and people unphased milling about.. We own this system. Now where’s the federal action at! Who’s with me for a strong Copenhagen Mr. Kerry?!

    -Eddie

  5. 5 Morgan Nov 20th, 2009 at 3:46 pm

    Craig, your passion comes through every word. I’m thrilled to see the amazing growth of this campaign.

  6. 6 Josh Lynch Nov 20th, 2009 at 7:46 pm

    Incredible! I was lucky enough to be with you all briefly the day you started the sleep-out. I have to say I’m really inspired by the results so far. Take care of yourself, Craig and keep up the fight! We’re with you in spirit here in Copenhagen.

  7. 7 tuttle tuttle Nov 23rd, 2009 at 11:43 pm

    I see alot of problematic issues in this post and in the comments..

    “For better or for worse, it is illegal to be on the Boston Common after 11:00PM. While this ordinance was passed with the most sincere of intentions, one wonders what our forbearer’s would think of our Commonwealth when people receive citations for demonstrating on the Commons. Does democracy really close at 11:00PM?”

    What about Boston’s houseless population who gets arrested every night for sleeping on the commons, and are now enduring even more heat from the fascist police because of a bunch of privileged college kids calling themselves revolutionaries? this ordinance was passed with the most sincere of intentions of making it even more illegal to be homeless in this capitalist system designed to take the most money from the working class and poor as possible. democracy doesn’t close at 11pm, democracy doesn’t even exist in this country.

    And to Eddie Miller:
    we own this system?
    fuck you, take an anti oppression training. better yet, read up on political prisoners, abused women and trans people, white supremacy, classism, patriarchy and capitalism death culture and until you do don’t say another word.

  8. 8 Gabriel Elsner Nov 25th, 2009 at 12:41 pm

    Tuttle Tuttle – no one appreciates your pessimism on this blog. Find another place to spew your hateful rhetoric

  9. 9 Jesse Jenkins Dec 3rd, 2009 at 5:37 pm

    Craig,

    I am so impressed by you and the Leadership Campaign. I hope your examples serves to lead not just Massachusetts towards a clean and just energy future, but the broader youth movement towards bolder and more effective action around a truly concrete, ambitious and aspirational goal. With you in spirit from the Left Coast. In solidarity,
    Jesse

  10. 10 Ted Glick Dec 4th, 2009 at 7:13 am

    Craig and all the others,

    Congratulations on a great action. This is truly the kind of leadership we need if we’re to have a fighting chance of winning.

    Today is the 29th day of the Climate Justice Fast (www.climatejusticefast.com), which I’ve been on for all of those days, half on water-only, half on liquids, and I’ll be going back to water-only on Monday when the Copenhagen conference starts. Seven people have been on water-only the entire time.

    Across the miles, each in our different ways, we’re stepping it up, as we have to keep doing until, yes, we win.

    Ted Glick

  1. 1 Why We Fight « It’s Getting Hot In Here Trackback on Dec 3rd, 2009 at 10:29 am
  2. 2 Why We Fight Trackback on Jan 17th, 2010 at 1:47 pm
Comments are currently closed.

About Craig


Craig Altemose is the founder and Executive Director of Better Future Project, which engages in movement-building to make communities more resilient and to accelerate a rapid and responsible transition away from fossil fuels. Currently, he serves on the Massachusetts Green Economy and Climate Protection Advisory Committee and on the board of the Mass Climate Action Network. Craig founded and led Students for a Just and Stable Future (MA's state network). He has previously served as a member of the Executive Committee of the Massachusetts Chapter of the Sierra Club, the Co-Chair of the National Association of Environmental Law Societies, worked with Energy Action as an intern and a fellow, and served on the Executive Committee of the Sierra Student Coalition, a group he remains active with. Craig helped plan Power Shift 2007, and was the Lead Organizer of the Massachusetts Power Shift conference in April, 2008. He holds a Juris Doctorate from Harvard Law School, a Master in Public Policy from the John F. Kennedy School of Government and a B.A. in International Relations and Global Affairs from Eckerd College.

Community Picks