NYT and Sen. Rockefeller Agree: “‘Clean’ Coal is Dirty”

t1homerockefellergiAs the Power Past Coal project launches, we see some big news from Capitol Hill and the media regarding the demise of so-called “clean coal.”

First, in the Senate confirmation hearing for new Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner, longtime West Virginia Senator Jay Rockefeller (pictured) started a ramble about energy politics that surprised all in attendance when he remarked, “Coal is dirty. ‘Clean coal’ is dirty.” (You can watch a video and read an analysis by our friends at WonkRoom here) While Sen. Rockefeller was incorrect in his speech when he claimed that there are two coal-fired power plants in the country that sequester their carbon emissions (in reality, no such plants exist), we can hope that his new-found distaste for coal can help us guarantee that we transition coal out of America’s energy future.  

From the pages of the New York Times comes an editorial entitled “Collapse of the Clean Coal Myth.” It seems that the hard work of clean energy advocates, Appalachian residents, and bloggers have paid off and the massive TVA coal ash spill will not dissolve into the background. The Times’ editorial board highlights Senator Barabara Boxer (D-CA) and her new efforts to regulate coal ash in the wake of one of the biggest environmental disasters in recent history. Also highlighted is a court case in North Carolina in which a judge mandated that four coal-fired power plants must reduce thier carbon emissions as the pollution is a “public nuisance” to the residents of the state.

These actions show us that the movement against coal is gaining steam. Power Past Coal’s 100 days of action will help propel our stories from statehouse to statehouse, from the Capitol to the White House. Already many Americans are hosting actions across the country, sharing how coal affects their lives and how they stand to benefit from a switch to a clean energy economy. People like Elouise Brown, a Dine woman who has spent the past three years working to stop the construction of new coal power plants on her Navajo reservation.

Take Action. Tell Your Story. Join the Movement

2 Responses to “NYT and Sen. Rockefeller Agree: “‘Clean’ Coal is Dirty””


  1. 1 Marty Jan 23rd, 2009 at 5:21 pm

    great post with some key links! I had heard about this from a friend as was waiting for one of us to pick up on it. Thanks for putting this up!

  2. 2 SRC Jan 24th, 2009 at 5:45 pm

    Seems like your reporting is a little lop-sided and mis-guided. Mr. Rockefeller goes on to say:

    “The United States has more than a 250-year supply of coal, and a lot of it is mined by hard-working people in West Virginia,” Rockefeller said. “As a coal state senator, I believe that there can be no serious discussions about our energy future or climate change unless we’re willing to make immediate, significant and sustained investments in carbon capture and sequestration.

    “Advanced coal technologies have to be part of the solution to our nation’s energy independence, and should be included as part of economic stimulus.”

    “There is no time to waste,” Rockefeller said “Deploying advanced coal technologies will create jobs for West Virginians and people across America, and they will put our country on the path toward energy independence, which is exactly what we need to achieve if we’re going to have a thriving economy again.”

Comments are currently closed.

About Ben


Ben Wessel is a 21-year old student at Middlebury College in Middlebury, VT. Growing up in Washington, DC he has always been fascinated by politics, and feels that strong legislation and real advocacy efforts from the grassroots, particularly young people, will be a main factor in solving the climate crisis. His passion for activism, policy, and adventure has taken him from a WWF-sponsored "Voyage for the Future" in the Norwegian Arctic to the UN Climate Change Negotiations in Poznan, Poland and Copenhagen to the halls of Congress and Capitol Hill with 1Sky and Powershift '07 '09. Most recently, Ben helped lead the "Race to Replace Vermont Yankee," a youth clean energy voter campaign in Vermont that helped support clean energy candidates for Governor and other elected positions in Vermont. When not geeking out the latest CBO scoring of climate legislation, he is likely to be found snowboarding, cooking, or rooting for the Washington Redskins.

Community Picks