Is Nuclear Renewable? Not in South Carolina.

South Carolina nuclear lobbyists held their hopes high this past week as members of the South Carolina House Agricultural Committee attempted to alter a renewable energy bill to define nuclear as a ‘renewable’ energy source. After much outrage over the ridiculousness of calling uranium (a finite resource that demands fossil-fuels intensive extraction and processing if it is to be utilized) a renewable energy source, the Ag Committee was pressed to change the wording from Renewable to “Clean”.

The new wording promised to secure loop-holes to make it easier for utility companies to meet future energy efficiency/clean energy standards. This excited the nuclear industry, especially after construction costs have sky-rocketed and caused at least one plant to cancel its plans in the state.

But none the less, even as our Nation’s presidential candidates continue to push the doublespeak rhetoric that calls for clean coal and safe nuclear solutions to our dangerous addictions to coal and nuclear, South Carolina House Representatives denied the proposed definition.

The decision came after an amendment was offered that appealed to House Representatives interest in growing a large renewable manufacturing industry in the state, by stating that it would be harder for entrepreneurs in the industry to find state and federal funding. The definition which included Nuclear as Renewable was shut-down with a solid 114-0 Vote!

3 Responses to “Is Nuclear Renewable? Not in South Carolina.”


  1. 1 Pluto Boy Feb 10th, 2008 at 12:39 pm

    Lurking behind the scenes of this ridiculous “nukes are renewable” debate in South Carolina was the idea of reprocessing spent nuclear fuel and using plutonium breeder reactors. Several mal-informed and brain washed (by Duke Energy?) representatives spoke up in favor of reprocessing every chance they got. Reprocessing dissolves spent reactor uclear fuel in acid, creating a sea of waste, and removes weapons-usable plutonium for stockpiling. The industry can only exist if propped up by big government. In the S.C, Bush and his Department of Energy is pursuing it through a program called the Global Nuclear Energy Partnership (GNEP) and DOE has requested $302 million for this in Fiscal Year 2009. The DOE’s Savannah River Site in S.C. is a target for this insane GNEP program. While some call it recycling, that only applies in that pursuit of this program recycles money out of your pocket and right into that of the plutonium industry and political allies.

  2. 2 Abe Mar 16th, 2008 at 9:23 pm

    There’s enough uranium in the Earth to power civilization for billions of years, and it’s constantly brought to the surface and dissolved in seawater by cycles of erosion and uplift. There’s absolutely no shortage of fuel; it will last longer than the sun itself.

    The only problem is waste, and how harmful is that? Seriously, compare the environmental impact of nuclear waste with the alternatives: coal power plant pollution and global warming. Which is worse?

  3. 3 John May 5th, 2009 at 2:00 pm

    How can nuclear waste be called “clean”? It’s the dirtiest waste known to man! It causes damage to DNA and leeches into our water and food supply for the next 30,000 years regardless of how we try to contain it. South Carolina will cease to exist if these money hungry, pocket lining out of control capitolist bastards don’t realize that people are already starting to be affected by their “clean” nuclear waste. For the last 40 years no one in my family had cancer. Now within the last 5 years my grandmother, maternal cousin, paternal cousin, and close high school friends have all developed cancer. Many more unmentioned have also. South Carolina already has more nuclear power plants per capita than any other place in the world. Now the money mongers have approval to build 12 more plants in the next 20 years. Duh, fusion will be available soon and SC will be stuck with fission and will become an uninhabitable wasteland. I’m a sailor. I’ve sailed in SC for 21 years. There is wind here! But the fools won’t even dream of using real “clean” technology. I’m leaving SC for good; you greedy assholes can have your waste dump!

Comments are currently closed.

About Seth


Community Picks