The People’s Car Arrives…

No Tigers?It is 8:30 pm on January 10th, 2008. I am writing from the famous Ranthambore National Park–known for its tigers–where 80% of the world’s “tiger in the wild” photos are taken. I have been on two game drives and seen no tigers. It is said that there are somewhere between 30 o 40 tigers in this 400 sq. km sanctuary. Much has been done to protect the species from certain extinction on his subcontinent of 1.03 billion people. Here the battle that will determine which India wins–the urban/”shining India” or the rural/depressed India–is being waged on the basis of land. As people are moved out of parks to make way for non-community based conservation in this part of India, on the eastern side of the country people are being bought off (forcibly) from productive farm lands to make way for an auto manufacturing plant. This single manufacturing plant is going to redefine the way the world moves–starting with the Indians.

It is 8:45 pm on January 10th, 2008 and on TV I am seeing the long awaited release of the “People’s Car” by India’s Tata Motors. The car is the cheapest the world has seen yet with a base price of Rs. 1 Lakh (US$2500)–all of this having met the Indian safety standards as well as pollution standards (Euro IV). The idea was to provide a car within easier reach of India’s burgeoning middle class and despite all the nay-sayers, Tata may have pulled this off. It is a four door car with a 33 hrs power engine and it is called the “Nano.” This name being chosen to signify the innovation possibilities (of doing a lot with a little) thanks to improvements in technology. Unfortunately the car may be diesel powered - wreaking havoc on the reduced suspended particulates achieved in cities like New Delhi through forced use of Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) by he city’s public transport. However it is said to have fuel efficiency of 20 km/L or 50 mpg–which is just as good as any Japanese Hybrid. And if the world DOES figure out biofuels, then the diesel engine may not be so bad.

Whether this car will truly benefit the “common man,” presumably those living in ruralRatan Tata with Tata Nano areas as argued by some of the car’s advocates, or simply turn into a traffic and pollution nightmare for the already taxed urban Indian–is yet to be seen. Rest assured its impact will send ripple effects across the globe–be it global fuel price or temperature rise (and I won’t even mention the hike in consumption of resources used for the construction of the vehicle–yes it’s steel!).

It is 9:00pm on January 10th, 2008. The world will look back on this day surely. I do not know whether I will see any tigers tomorrow either, but I know that I am a little bit more uncertain about their future in this new India which has turned yet another page on its path of industrialization.

Tigers: Here today, gone tomorrow?

Tata Nano: Coming soon to a store near…you?

*Jan. 11, 2008* I did not see any tigers today and I found out that none have been spotted within the last few days by anyone on a game drive.

6 Responses to “The People’s Car Arrives…”


  1. 1 addy Jan 11th, 2008 at 3:51 pm

    Does anybody know about this site ( http://www.earthlab.com ) ? I have seen other environmental sites with carbon calculators like yahoo and tree huggers, but I am wondering what the deal with earthlab.com is? I saw they also published a list last month of the top ten greenest cities ( http://www.efficientenergy.org/Top-Ten-Green-Cities-in-the-United-States ). Does anyone know if this site is better than the others? Fill me in!

    I took their carbon foot print test and it was pretty interesting, they said that I put out 4.5 tons of carbon, does anyone know about any other tests?

  2. 2 Cascadia Brian Jan 11th, 2008 at 5:46 pm

    A lot of people seem not too happy about this car!

    “Fiery protest over Tata’s Nano”
    http://www.news.com/8301-10784_3-9848763-7.html?tag=nefd.top

  3. 3 mbjesq Jan 11th, 2008 at 6:58 pm

    The “people’s car” is a wonderful example of India’s mid-20st Century mindset and its squandered chance at 21st Century development. My short essay on this can be read at http://memestreamblog.wordpress.com/2007/10/12/india-going-nowhere-fast/.

    MBJ

  4. 4 Anne O'Brien Jan 11th, 2008 at 8:08 pm

    “the world figuring out biofuels”-

    -as in the world figures out how NOT to use valuable agricultural land for growing agrofuel crops, displacing local people and driving up the global cost of food…

    i don’t think that market forces, as they are currently operating, are figuring out an adequate solution for mass produced agro-fuels, versus feeding the world.

  5. 5 Kartikeya Singh Jan 12th, 2008 at 12:39 pm

    Yes, “figuring out biofuels” requires a lot–to start with, forget about using food and productive lands as a means to do so. Has anyone heard about Jatropha? It is being touted as the miracle plant that can be grown on marginal land and is drought resistant. not only this but it increases the productivity of the soil. It can be a boost to rural economies as it can decentralize the production of fuel in rural areas. Time will tell whether it really is a cure-all because corporations are flying in to make big bucks off it. Also, some have said that perhaps it DOES require water.

  6. 6 AV Jan 18th, 2008 at 9:32 pm

    Karthik, you are the man!

Leave a Reply




About Kartikeya


Kartikeya Singh, born in Jodhpur, India, moved to South Bend, Indiana in 1993 and has been a resident of Greenville, South Carolina since 2001. A graduate of Furman University, he designed his own major titled "Ecology & Sustainable Development" (BSc.). This interdisciplinary major allowed him to study phyto-remediation in Puerto Rico, marine ecosystems in Belize, wildlife management in South Africa and Kenya, and water issues in India. During this last year on Compton Mentor Fellowship, he conducted research on decentralized renewable energy sources for rural areas in India. An unexpected result of being part of the SustainUS Bali delegation was his being a founding member of the Indian Youth Climate Network of which he is now Executive Director. This year Kartikeya will be formalizing this rapidly expanding network (and also ensuring that an Indian youth delegation finds itself in Poland) with the hopes to start his Masters in Environmental Management at Yale in the fall of 2009.

Power Vote Twitter!

Follow live updates from the Power Vote Campaign and the Clean Energy Movement with the Power Vote Twitter feed

Flickr Photos

DSC_0419.JPG

DSC_0316.JPG

DSC_0089.JPG

DSC_0314_2.JPG

More Photos
block.png