White House Puts the Muzzle on CDC Testimony on Health Effects of Global Warming

The White House is at it again, censoring expert testimony on Global Warming. This time the Bush Administration cut out over half of Center for Disease Control Director Julie Gerberding’s Senate testimony on the public health effects of climate change.

The White House PR machine first tried to pass the Administration’s edits off as “minor edits.” DeSmogBlog blows away that argument with a comparison between the Gerberding’s original testimony and the final version after the White House got through with it.

The White House cut the original version down from 3,100 words to only 1,500, completely wiping out whole sections on health related effects due to extreme weather, air pollution-related health effect, allergic diseases, water and food-borne infectious diseases, food and water scarcity and the long term impacts of chronic diseases and other health effects.

Then the White House shifted tune, saying that they had removed the sections because they conflicted with findings from the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.

Several Congressional Democrats, including Senate Environment and Public Works Committee Chair, Barbara Boxer (D-CA), promptly called bull$h!t.

Boxer’s office published a paragraph-by-paragraph comparison of the deleted sections of Dr. Gerberding’s testimony and the IPCC report on how climate change will affect public health.

Needless to say, the comparison reveals striking similarities, not conflicting reports.

According to NewsDay.com:

Both [Dr. Gerberdin and the IPCC] raised virtually identical concerns: heat stress on vulnerable populations; the likelihood of respiratory illnesses from increased air pollution; the spread of waterborne infectious diseases; and more injuries from severe weather events such as wildfires.

Nice try President Bush. What’s the next lie … er … “spin”, you want to put on this story?

[A hat tip to the crew at DeSmogBlog's excellent muckraking.]

3 Responses to “White House Puts the Muzzle on CDC Testimony on Health Effects of Global Warming”


  1. 1 jessejenkins Oct 26th, 2007 at 4:38 pm

    How many times do you need to lie to get impeached in this country? Just once when it comes to sex, but apparently at least a few dozen when it comes to beating the drums of war and fussing around with the fate of the world as we know it…

  2. 2 Amy Ortiz Oct 27th, 2007 at 4:50 pm

    seriously! These criminals are creating an unstable, dangerous world for us WITH our tax money. However, sometimes it seems like they will get away with it all.

  3. 3 energyguru Oct 28th, 2007 at 12:12 pm

    people need to stop talking and debating about these problems on a national level and just do something about them @ HOME!!!

Leave a Reply




About Jesse


Jesse is an energy and climate policy analyst, activist and blogger. He is currently the director of energy and climate policy at the Breakthrough Institute where he helps develop and advance new energy solutions to power America's future, secure our energy freedom, and halt global warming. Jesse joined the Breakthrough team in June 2008 to co-direct the Breakthrough Generation Summer Fellows Program. Before joining the Breakthrough Institute, Jesse spent two years as a Research and Policy Associate at the Renewable Northwest Project where he worked to advance the development of the Pacific Northwest's abundant renewable energy potential. While at RNP, he helped pass two statewide renewable energy standards (in WA and OR) and block plans to build 800 MW of new coal plants. In the past, Jesse has worked as a researcher and software developer with the Department of Physics at the University of Oregon, where he focused on alternative vehicles and fuels, and as a teacher's assistant in energy studies courses at the university. Jesse has a history of grassroots climate and energy activism and co-founded the Cascade Climate Network, the Northwest's largest network of youth working to tackle the climate crisis and build a sustainable, just, and prosperous future. An active blogger since 2005, Jesse is the founder and blogmaster of the site, WattHead - Energy News and Commentary. He currently writes at several sites throughout the blogosphere, including ItsGettingHotInHere.org, Cleanergy.org, DailyKos, Scitizen.com and The Energy Collective. Jesse's writing has also been featured in the San Francisco Chronicle and Baltimore Sun. Jesse is a graduate of the Robert D. Clark Honors College at the University of Oregon (magna cum laude), where he completed an interdisciplinary course of study in computer science, philosophy, liberal arts, political science & energy studies. In fulfillment of his honors degree, Jesse completed an undergraduate honors thesis entitled, On the Road to Replacing Oil - A Well-to-Wheels Study Exploring Alternative Transportation Fuels and Energy Sources. Jesse currently lives in Berkeley, California.

Live updates from the field