Obama and Clinton Need to Do Better

MoveOn.Org just held a straw poll on climate change, and John Edwards won by a landslide. Over 100,000 voted based on short video responses to questions asked by MoveOn members, and Edwards got 33% – more than the next two candidates (Kucinich and Obama) combined. See the press release here.

None of the candidates are where they should be on this. It’s particularly disheartening that the front-runners, Obama and Clinton, haven’t offered a plan remotely to the scale of the problem.

Dan Carol, a co-founder of the Apollo Alliance, wrote a brilliant open letter in the Huffington Post to Obama urging him to match his bold rhetoric with a bold plan:

My gut is that the answer lies in marrying a call to national service around energy efficiency and independence – getting young and old, union worker and apprentice, city and rural, black and brown and white, retrofitting a new America and busy creating the jobs and industries of tomorrow. This is hardly a new idea, but no one yet owns the idea in this campaign. To own it you need to bet big and go all in, Texas hold-em style.

People want the whole enchilada – new federal R&D and clean energy earmarks in every Congressional district, national service to weatherize the 13 million homes that remain eligible for federal assistance (many in inner cities), and I’ll even bet Americans would reach into their pockets and buy freedom bonds to invest even more if they knew the jobs created would stay at home.

This is an idea whose time has come, but the key is scale. An initiative like this could pay for itself over time with the energy savings it would generate, but it would require an upfront investment of at least $50 billion. That’s a little over 4 months in Iraq and Afganistan, according to recent estimates of the cost of those conflicts.

Any bets on which candidate will get there first? Any ideas on what we can do to help get them there?

2 Responses to “Obama and Clinton Need to Do Better”


  1. 1 mattreitman Jul 16th, 2007 at 11:53 pm

    I think it will be much easier to move political targets in areas that don’t make lots of money from dirty energy. Obama, bless his heart, comes from a coal state. The majority of Illinois lies above the Illinois Coal Basin. It’s hard to tell how much this would affect him as a national leader.

    Some call this a political reality, I call it fascism…Really, I think we both mean the same thing. One of the interesting pieces of this is that energy reserves don’t align cleanly with the existing geography of political power, so there is a lot of opportunity for non-traditional players in this puzzle.

  1. 1 Obama Steps Up…When Will Clinton? « It’s Getting Hot In Here Trackback on Oct 12th, 2007 at 12:48 pm
Comments are currently closed.

About Billy


At the end of 2002, freaked out about the deepening climate crisis, Billy dropped out of Yale University in the middle of his junior year to build a youth movement. He co-founded and led the Energy Action Coalition, which has become the largest youth advocacy organization in the world working on clean energy and global warming issues. Since early 2008, Billy has expanded his work beyond the Energy Action Coalition into a focus on building the green economy and creating green jobs for young people. He has been a consultant for Green for All on their "Green Jobs Now" day of action and developed the idea and campaign to create a Clean Energy Corps, a proposal based on the Civilian Conservation Corps designed to rebuild the country and create millions of new jobs and opportunities for community service. The community service component, The Clean Energy Service Corps, has become law as part of the Serve America Act, and other components of the proposal have been incorporated into the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act and the American Clean Energy and Security Act. A serial social entrepreneur, Billy has helped launch dozens of youth, climate and green jobs related organizations and initiatives, including Green Owl Records, a green music label affiliated with Warner Music Group; The Navajo Green Economy Coalition, which recently passed groundbreaking green jobs legislation on the Navajo Nation; and the Alignment Process, a collaborative of 50 large progressive organizations working on passing strong federal legislation to build a green economy and address global warming. Originally from New York City, he now lives with his wife Wahleah Johns and daughter Tohaana in Flagstaff, AZ.

Community Picks